The alleged killer, Darren Martell Jr., pleaded not guilty in a St. Albans courtroom on Friday to a charge of aggravated murder — the most severe charge under state law, which carries a minimum sentence of life in prison without parole.
Roberta Martin disappeared from her Butternut Hollow Road home, where she lived alone, sometime between 11:30 p.m. on July 16 and noon the following day, when a pair of neighbors reported her missing.
The neighbors, close friends of Martin’s, had gone to check on her at the request of Martin’s daughter, according to police. At Martin’s home, they discovered her air conditioner had been removed from a window and was on the front porch. The sliding glass door was open, and Martin was gone, state police investigators recounted in an affidavit filed in court on Friday.
As search crews looked for Martin, investigators homed in on Martell Jr., who had recently begun living in a camper in the neighbors’ backyard. The Department for Children and Families told investigators that Martell Jr. had a history of “assaultive behavior” toward his girlfriend. The woman also reported that Martell Jr. had stolen a relative’s underwear and “implied that he used them for sexual gratification.”
A sister to Martell’s girlfriend later told investigators that Martell Jr. and his girlfriend had asked her grandmother to tell police that Martell Jr. was at her home on the night that Martin disappeared.
On July 18, police executed a search warrant on the camper and seized Martell Jr.’s property. Days later, they learned that Martell Jr. used a wooded area near Sand Hill Road to grow marijuana. At the location, less than a mile from Martin’s residence, police said they found a gas can and Martin’s remains, which were scattered and “appeared to be burned.”
The day after discovering Martin’s remains, Vermont State Police detectives found Martell Jr. on a public path in St. Albans. He was masturbating, police allege. Martell Jr. ran into the wood, forcing a local school into lockdown, before police arrested him. He has been incarcerated at Northwest State Correctional Facility since Monday on a charge of lewd and lascivious conduct.
Following that arrest, Martell Jr. told police that he had never spoken to Martin nor been at her property. But vaginal swabs from Martin’s body found sperm with DNA that “preliminarily” matched that of Martell Jr.
Numerous members of Martin’s family attended Martell Jr.’s arraignment on Friday afternoon in St. Albans but declined to speak to the press. A public defender representing Martell Jr. contested whether the evidence submitted by state police was enough to support the murder charge, noting the lack of a cause-of-death finding or other evidence tying Martell Jr. to the crime scenes.
State police and prosecutors are tightly controlling information about the case and declined to say much beyond what was included in the court affidavit.
“My office, the Franklin County State’s Attorney’s Office, is committed to holding the perpetrator of this act accountable and bringing him to justice,” Kranichfeld said.
Got something to say?
Send a letter to the editor and we'll publish your feedback in print!
